It's too dark with no payoff. Great performances by Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey, but all the best parts were in the trailer. It's sad, too, because it could have been really good.
Shane (1953) - 4/5
This is a classic old western so the pace is slower than modern films tend to be, but it adds to the mood and the movie's better for it. Nice slow build of tension and stakes, so that it's much more of a drama than an action piece. Some spotty acting in various places, and the argument about why the heroes do what they do was unsatisfyingly off the mark. But I can certainly see why Logan referenced it so heavily.