Where Eagles Dare - 4/5

This movie is one of the most understated action movies of the last century. Most of the film isn’t action, but a long cat-and-mouse buildup to lay the groundwork for the action-packed finale. It’s a multi-layered plot and plays its cards close to the chest, cueing the audience in that there’s more going on but not explaining what exactly until the end. It’s an incredibly solid WWII stealth action film and is a must-watch for fans of the genre.

Closest comparison: It’s like The Guns of Navarone by way of The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly.

Setting: WWII Action
Plot: Infiltration
Tone: Drama / Action

Secret Agent (1936) -3/5

Better than The 39 Steps, this movie at least has an interesting turn in the middle. Instead of plot contrivances it actually takes a meta-commentary on films with plot contrivances and bakes it into the plot. Peter Lorre is marvelous here, as always, and the cast has chemistry and is well-suited to their individual roles. Unfortunately the ending leaves quite a bit to be desired, opting for more of a ‘that’s all, folks’ wrap-up than a more satisfying ‘Hitchcockian’ twist. Still, it’s good film-making overall and a fun older movie.

Closest comparison: It’s a more interesting 39 Steps

Setting: WWI
Plot: Spy
Tone: Spy

The 39 Steps - 3/5

Alfred Hitchcock knows how to weave a story, but here it seems like he’s just going through the motions. It’s fine enough, with some nice cinematography and a few fun bits of witty banter, but it lacks the life and excitement of many of his other films. There are too many plot conveniences, too many things that happen just the right way, and the ending is a mildly clumsy reveal, not the clever discovery one comes to expect from the Master of Suspense. Still, you could do a whole lot worse when it comes to the spy genre, and on the whole it’s pretty entertaining.

Closest Comparison: It’s like The Third Man but less pretentious and 14 years earlier.

Setting: Modern (1930’s)
Plot: Spy Thriller
Tone: Spy Thriller