Three Amigos! - 3/5

This movie uses primarily the comedy framework of an awkward situation that goes on so long that it becomes funny, so comedy mileage may vary among audience members. That being said, the antics of Chevy Chase, Steve Martin, and Martin Short are on point and the trio of SNL veterans are having a blast hamming it up. It’s a classic for its comedy, not its depth.

Closest comparison: It’s like a cross between The Magnificent Seven and Galaxy Quest.

Setting: Western
Plot: Fish out of Water
Tone: Screwball Comedy

Oscar - 4/5

This is a classic stage-style comedy in the guise of a 1920’s mobster movie. It starts off a bit slow and takes its time speeding up, but once it gets up to speed it sings. A romanticized version of the amiable cultural sensibilities of the time come through in the best way, creating palpable style and blending with its stage play ambience to produce an immensely enjoyable shell game of misunderstandings and marriage proposals gone awry. It’s pleasant and joyful, a welcome change of pace.

Closest comparison: It’s like The Importance of Being Earnest in the garb of Mickey Blue Eyes

Setting: Gangster
Plot: Comedy of Errors
Tone: Dramedy